Search Optimization
  Home arrow Search Optimization arrow Are Meta Tags Extinct?
SEO Chat Forums  
Choosing Keywords  
Google Optimization  
Link Trading  
MSN Optimization  
Search Engine News  
Search Engine Spiders  
Search Optimization  
Web Directories  
Website Marketing  
Website Promotion  
Website Submission  
Yahoo Optimization  
SEO Tools
Adsense Calculator
AdSense Preview
Advanced Meta-Tags
Alexa Rank Tool
Check Server Headers
Class C Checker
Code to Text Ratio
CPM Calculator
Domain Age Check
Domain Typos
Future PageRank
Google Dance
Google Keywords
Google Search
Google Suggest
Google vs Yahoo
Indexed Pages
Keyword Cloud
Keyword Density
Keyword Difficulty
Keyword Optimizer
Keyword Position
Keyword Typos
Link Popularity
Link Price Calculator
Meta Analyzer
Meta Tag Generator
Multiple Link Popularity
Page Comparison
Page Size
PageRank Lookup
PageRank Search
Robots.txt Generator
ROI Calculator 
S.E. Comparison 
S.E. Keyword Position 
Site Link Analyzer 
Spider Simulator 
URL Redirect Check 
URL Rewriting 
Dedicated Servers  
Download TestComplete 
IBM® developerWorks 
SEO Weekly Newsletter
 
Developer Updates  
Free Website Content 
 RSS  Articles
 RSS  Forums
 RSS  All Feeds
Write For Us Get Paid 
Request Media Kit
Contact Us 
Site Map 
Privacy Policy 
Support 
 USERNAME
 
 PASSWORD
 
 
  >>> SIGN UP!  
  Lost Password? 
SEARCH OPTIMIZATION

Are Meta Tags Extinct?
By: Jennifer Sullivan Cassidy
  • Search For More Articles!
  • Disclaimer
  • Author Terms
  • Rating: 5 stars5 stars5 stars5 stars5 stars / 37
    2006-05-24

    Table of Contents:
  • Are Meta Tags Extinct?
  • Methodology
  • Results of the Experiment
  • Answers to Our Questions

  • Rate this Article: Poor Best 
      ADD THIS ARTICLE TO:
      Del.ici.ous Digg
      Blink Simpy
      Google Spurl
      Y! MyWeb Furl
    Email Me Similar Content When Posted
    Add Developer Shed Article Feed To Your Site
    Email Article To Friend
    Print Version Of Article
    PDF Version Of Article
     
     
     
    ADVERTISEMENT

    Dell PowerEdge Servers

    Are Meta Tags Extinct?
    (Page 1 of 4 )

    A few weeks ago, someone brought an interesting concept to my attention. They claimed that by not using keyword and description meta tags at all in their web pages, they were actually able to get better rankings in Google and Yahoo than before when they used the meta tags.

    I had never thought about this before, but I definitely started thinking about it since then.  Logically, it would make perfect sense that the search engines might completely disregard the meta tag information, and determine a page’s relevancy score based solely upon that page’s content.  After all, with all the abuse that the meta tags have sustained over the years, the best way to eliminate the spam issue is to ignore them completely.  But I think the concept is far more complicated than that.  What about those sites that intentionally misuse their meta tags to spam the search engines?  Do Google and Yahoo take that into account when determining relevancy score?  If so, then that means the search engines are not entirely disregarding the meta tags, because they certainly apply penalties for misuse of meta tags.  Or do they?  Further, if a web page is missing its meta tags, how will the search engines that still read them, like MSN, treat those pages?

    I could sit around all day and speculate, but the proof is in the pudding, so to speak.  So our firm decided to perform an experiment.  We chose six websites to use as our test group, and six others as our control group.  In the control group, we used naturally optimized sites that included meta tags.  In the test group, we utilized the same optimization techniques on the sites, with the exception of the meta tags, which we left out of the page completely.

    We knew we were going to have to wait for a Google update, so we wanted to watch these sites for at least six to eight weeks.  We analyzed statistics, keywords, page content and everything else that a good SEO firm should monitor when they are assessing the performance of websites.  We treated the test group no differently than we treated the control group.  Our only variable among these two groups of sites was the absence of meta keyword tags and meta description tags in the test group.

    More Search Optimization Articles
    More By Jennifer Sullivan Cassidy


       · An interesting article on a subject I've wondered about for a long time. My only...
       · 4 years late IMHO.
       · Are you saying the article is 4 years too late, or that meta tags should have been...
       · Thanks for your comment. Sorry if the article was a bit wordy :)At this point, I...
       · This is some very interesting research. I have had a sneaking suspicion that meta...
       · As an SEO I was interested to read the comments. Maybe this experiment would bring...
       · As it should be. Optimization is dead. Content/relevancy/Frequent site...
       · I think that makes SEO even easier. Two less things to worry about: meta keywords...
       · Ok, so they are not explicitly Meta Tags but Adobe PDF docuemnts heavily use Meta...
       · Interesting article. I've used well written and optimized description and keyword...
       · That it's not just PROFESSIONALS that visit this site. And while this information...
       · Putting something in the description that doesn't reflect what is already in your...
       · I definately have to back the author on this point. SEOchat is made for everyone....
       · JenI just wanted to say I really enjoyed this article and I hope you are...
       · Hi Jennifer,You have written an extremely thought-provoking article on a topic which...
       · Very interesting article. If for nothing more than posterity, someone wanted to hang...
       · I think there's a good chance that removing the meta keywords and description can...
       · Different professionals have their own innovative way of achieving their goal & that...
       · Thanks for this, it was a good read. I'd like to know more about your experiment...
       · Interesting article but my long term experience differs from your conclusions. I...
       · Thanks, Jenifer!I am a definite newbie webmaster and I appreciate your excellent...
       · Great post and research jennifer. Thanks for the info. As per some of your other...
     

    SEARCH OPTIMIZATION ARTICLES

    - Navigating Your Way into Your Visitors` Hear...
    - Creating SEO-Friendly Content
    - Network Solutions: Unethical SEO
    - Basic SEO: What Search Engines Hate
    - Basic SEO: What Search Engines Love
    - I, Robots.txt
    - Same Game, Different Name
    - Use SEO to Get Your New Site Off to a Good S...
    - Basic SEO Troubleshooting
    - Getting an SEO Education
    - Site Target Marketing
    - Costly SEO Mistakes You Must Avoid
    - Defending Against Black Hat and Negative SEO...
    - Scoring SEO Efforts Realistically
    - Don`t Make These Common SEO Mistakes!


     
    Accelerating Trading Partner Performance
     
    Competing on Analytics
     
    Cost Effective Scaling with Virtualization and Coyote Point Systems
     
    Five Checkpoints to Implementing IP Telephony
     
    Hosted Email Security: Staying Ahead of New Threats
     




    © 2003-2008 by Developer Shed. All rights reserved. DS Cluster 1 hosted by Hostway